• About Us
  • Write For Us
  • Advertising
  • Support
  • Contact Us
November 30, 2023 7:46 am CST
Heartland Newsfeed
  • Illinois
    • Local
      • Capital Area
      • East Central Illinois
      • West Central Illinois
    • Regional
      • Chicagoland
      • Metro-East
      • Northern Illinois
      • Quad Cities
      • Southern Illinois
    • Obits
    • Executive Watch
    • Legislative Watch
    • Road Conditions
      • Illinois
    • Weather Closings
      • Central Illinois
  • Missouri
    • Regional
      • Northeastern Missouri
      • East Central Missouri
      • St. Louis Metro
      • Southeast Missouri
    • Executive Watch
    • Legislative Watch
    • Weather Closings
      • Greater STL Metro (IL/MO)
    • Road Conditions
      • Missouri
  • Weather
  • National
  • World
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • OPINION
  • Radio
    • Affiliates
    • Network Schedule
    • Network Streams
    • Podcasts
  • Features
    • Business Directory
    • Classifieds
      • Current Ads
      • Job Board
        • Job Listings
        • J2CTalroo
        • Post a Job
        • Receive Alerts
        • ZipSearch
    • Community Calendar
    • Live Video
    • Newsfeeds
    • Puzzles & More
  • Store
  • Deals
  • Calendar
No Result
View All Result

No products in the cart.

Heartland Newsfeed
No Result
View All Result

EDWARDS: The Patent and Trademark Office — an enemy to America’s inventors

Guest Poster by Guest Poster
April 3, 2018
in Guest Posts, Opinion, Opinion-Editorial
Reading Time: 2 mins read
Donate
0
The Patent and Trademark Office, the federal agency charged with securing certain intellectual property, has become an enemy of America’s inventors. How is it that an office charged with protecting innovation is subverting it? In 2011, Congress passed the America Invents Act. This law included a number of provisions harmful to IP rights. Perhaps the worst was the establishment of new administrative procedures for challenging a patent’s validity. The abuse of this system has reached epidemic proportions. It’s time for Congress to restore integrity to the patent system. The new administrative process for challenges to existing patents, known as inter partes review, centers on a review by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, which proponents sold as a faster, cheaper alternative than taking patent challenges to court. The trouble is that PTAB proceedings are wildly unbalanced in favor of patent challengers. Federal court procedures provide a balanced, fair process and operate on a presumption that the patent, having been duly granted after review by the PTO, is valid. Yet the IPR procedures at PTAB, as one commenter put it, “are plagued by what in any other forum would be considered to be ‘procedural irregularity.'” First, anybody may file a PTAB challenge. This has enabled speculators, such as hedge funds with no interest in the patent or invention, to short the stock of a patent owner, then file for review simply to make a profit on the devalued stock. Second, PTAB sets a low standard of proof, so petitioners can easily wipe out property rights. This differs from the tougher standards in federal courts. Finally, there’s no protection of a challenged patent from “double jeopardy.” At PTAB, a patent may be challenged again and again. Thus, a patent owner may face a never-ending battle. The same patent can face a challenge in both the PTAB and federal district court. A federal court’s decision to uphold a patent doesn’t preclude PTAB from instituting a proceeding on the same patent — or even from overruling the court. Should the patent owner prevail, the victory consists entirely of the right to keep the patent — no damages or expenses. Only now, precious time has been lost on the patent term What has the PTAB regime led to, besides a clear and present danger to secure private property rights? More than one in three patents hauled into IPR has faced more than one request for review. Companies whose business centers on intellectual property frequently find themselves facing one or several IPR actions each time they seek to defend their patent rights. The IPR process invalidates an incredible 76 percent of the patent claims challenged. In contrast, district courts toss out 30 percent of challenged claims. Such uncertainty has devalued patents by two-thirds since the AIA became law. Thankfully, bipartisan legislation would address many of the excesses of the PTAB regime. The STRONGER Patents Act brings the balance and fairness of the federal courts to administrative challenges to patents. Nobody but lawyers likes expensive litigation. But if something entails high stakes — for example, billions of R&D dollars, years of trial and error, and the potential revocation of someone’s property rights — the proceedings making the determination between disputing parties must be fair. As it currently operates, PTAB isn’t. James Edwards is executive director of Conservatives for Property Rights and advises Eagle Forum Education and Legal Defense Fund on patent issues.
Guest Poster
+ posts
  • Guest Poster
    https://www.heartlandnewsfeed.com/author/guestposter/
    Six proven tips to keep your pipes clear this Thanksgiving
  • Guest Poster
    https://www.heartlandnewsfeed.com/author/guestposter/
    MARTY: Many factors can make or break a farm
  • Guest Poster
    https://www.heartlandnewsfeed.com/author/guestposter/
    LETTERS: Ranked choice voting
  • Guest Poster
    https://www.heartlandnewsfeed.com/author/guestposter/
    JASE Medical is disrupting the medical industry
Tags: AmericainventorsPatentPatent and Trademark Officetrademark
Share196Tweet123Share5Send
  • Workforce training center opens in Litchfield

    1498 shares
    Share 599 Tweet 375
  • Cougars, Salukis settle for tie

    1211 shares
    Share 484 Tweet 303
  • Missouri law to crack down on porch pirates

    981 shares
    Share 392 Tweet 245
  • Missouri Dems critical of proposed tax cut

    959 shares
    Share 384 Tweet 240
  • No management pay raises in UPS deal

    918 shares
    Share 367 Tweet 230

OPERATING HOURS

Online all the time 
Office Hours: 8 AM to 8 PM

Sitemap | Published Press | Privacy Policy
Staff Email | Independent Media | Buy traffic for your website

LIVE WEBSITE VIEWERS

Some rights reserved 2017-2023 by Heartland Newsfeed, a subsidiary partnership by Heartland Internet Media Networks and Heartland Media Group of Central Illinois LLC. Content published by Heartland Newsfeed staff is covered by the BipCot NoGov license. This allows use and re-use by anyone except governments and government agents. License on record. JNews theme designed and developed by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • World
    • Science
  • Entertainment
    • Gaming
    • Music
    • Movie
    • Sports
  • Tech
    • Apps
    • Gear
    • Mobile
    • Startup
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Health
    • Travel

Some rights reserved 2017-2023 by Heartland Newsfeed, a subsidiary partnership by Heartland Internet Media Networks and Heartland Media Group of Central Illinois LLC. Content published by Heartland Newsfeed staff is covered by the BipCot NoGov license. This allows use and re-use by anyone except governments and government agents. License on record. JNews theme designed and developed by Jegtheme.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

WP Radio
WP Radio
OFFLINE LIVE
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
-
00:00
00:00

Queue

Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00